In a sudden and politically charged development, Dr. Krishnamurthy Subramanian, the Executive Director (India) at the International Monetary Fund (IMF), has been relieved of his duties by the Indian government. The announcement, made on Saturday, has stirred significant attention across economic, political, and social circles in India.

While the Appointment Committee of the Cabinet (ACC) did not offer a public explanation for the termination, a series of recent controversies, internal tensions, and external diplomatic scenarios offer insight into the abrupt move.

A Polarising Economist with a Bold Approach

Dr. Subramanian, a well-known economist and former Chief Economic Adviser to the Government of India, had assumed the role at the IMF with much expectation. His credentials were lauded across policy circles, and he was seen as a rising figure in India's economic diplomacy.

However, he also drew attention — and criticism — for some controversial statements and projections, including his claim that India’s GDP would reach $55 trillion by 2047. This figure was widely questioned by economists and politicians alike, with many branding it unrealistic and misleading.

Kerala Congress’s Scathing Reaction

The termination was welcomed, rather sarcastically, by the Kerala unit of the Congress party. In a strongly worded post on X (formerly Twitter), the party said:

“We are glad that the government has finally realised the embarrassment he could cause, even by their standards.”

The party also mocked his economic assessments, particularly his $55 trillion GDP projection, calling it “nonsense”. In a final jab, the post added:

“Now Mr. Subramanian can return to WhatsApp University as a full-time faculty.”

This satirical reference is frequently used on Indian social media to mock misinformation or pseudo-intellectual discourse.

Possible Reasons Behind the Government's Decision

Though no official reason has been cited by the Cabinet, two primary theories are circulating based on insider sources and media reports:

1. Rising Diplomatic Tensions with Pakistan

With the IMF scheduled to review Pakistan’s financial condition on May 9, Subramanian’s continued presence — viewed as assertive and at times critical — may have been seen as a risk to India’s diplomatic position. Given the ongoing tensions between India and Pakistan, his vocal role at the IMF may have been deemed counterproductive to the nation's interests.

2. Friction with IMF Officials

Reports also suggest that IMF officials were displeased with Subramanian’s persistent questioning of their datasets and analytical credibility. While some viewed this as a bold and necessary stance, others within the IMF reportedly found it disruptive and uncooperative.

Adding to the friction was the release and promotion of his book, “India@100: Envisioning Tomorrow’s Economic Powerhouse.”
Some IMF officials allegedly raised concerns over the publicity efforts for the book, hinting at potential impropriety — especially considering that he was holding an influential global post during the promotional period.

The India@100 Book Row

"India@100", penned by Dr. Subramanian, paints an ambitious picture of India as an economic giant by its 100th year of independence. While the book has attracted a certain readership and admiration, critics argue that it lacks a grounded and data-backed approach, with many of its projections bordering on the speculative.

The concern, especially from the IMF’s side, seemed to revolve around whether his role as a public intellectual promoting a book conflicted with his responsibilities as a representative of a sovereign nation at an international financial institution.

A Pattern of Assertiveness

Throughout his academic and professional career, Subramanian has cultivated an image of being bold, outspoken, and unapologetically nationalistic. While this has earned him respect among certain circles in India, his style may have been less compatible with the collaborative and cautious nature of diplomacy required at multilateral institutions like the IMF.

His tenure at the IMF was marked by frequent commentary on global financial governance, often pushing for reform and a more equitable role for developing nations. While this advocacy is seen as vital, the tone and manner of its delivery may have alienated allies and stakeholders.

Political Implications and Reactions

Subramanian’s termination also raises questions about the internal dynamics of India’s economic policymaking. The Centre’s decision to sack a figure it had once appointed to a prestigious international position reflects possible discontent or a strategic shift in approach.

Opposition parties, especially the Congress, have seized this moment to highlight what they call “failure in judgment” by the Modi-led government in both appointing and retaining him for so long.

What Lies Ahead for Subramanian?

With his IMF chapter now closed, all eyes will be on what Dr. Krishnamurthy Subramanian chooses to pursue next. Whether he returns to academia, takes on a role in policy consulting, or indeed embraces the jibe of becoming a ‘WhatsApp University faculty’, remains to be seen.

Given his high-profile persona, sharp views, and experience in top-level economic advisory roles, he is unlikely to stay away from the spotlight for long.

Conclusion

The termination of Dr. Krishnamurthy Subramanian from the IMF marks more than just the end of a tenure — it opens up conversations about diplomatic conduct, the balance between public advocacy and official responsibility, and the limits of nationalist rhetoric in international platforms.

While his economic vision may still influence debates in India, this episode serves as a reminder that holding a global post demands not only expertise but also diplomacy, balance, and consensus-building.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are Srigee DLM, Manoj Jewellers.

The Current active IPO are Wagons Learning, Kenrik Industries.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.