Mohsen Mahdawi, a Palestinian student and activist at Columbia University, made headlines after his release from detention by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Mahdawi was arrested during a citizenship interview, a move his legal team argued was politically motivated due to his lead role in protests against Israel’s war in Gaza.

A U.S. District Judge Geoffrey Crawford granted his release, stating that Mahdawi raised a "substantial claim" that his arrest was an attempt by the government to silence dissenting political speech. The judge affirmed that Mahdawi's conduct was protected under the First Amendment, even if it offended political figures or caused discomfort to the U.S. State Department.

Mahdawi’s Background and Legal Battle

Mahdawi, 34 years old, moved to the U.S. in 2014 from a refugee camp in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. He has been a legal permanent resident for 10 years. His contributions to campus life at Columbia included co-founding the Palestinian Student Union alongside Mahmoud Khalil, another Palestinian student who remains detained.

Mahdawi had been held since April 14 in a Vermont state prison, making his legal struggle one of the first of its kind to result in the student’s release. Upon walking out of court, he was welcomed by a large crowd of supporters, whom he led in chants of “Free Palestine” and “No fear.”

Judge’s Ruling Draws Historical Parallels

Judge Crawford’s ruling strongly criticized the government's actions, likening recent student arrests to crackdowns during the Red Scare and McCarthy era. He referenced the 1919–1920 raids on suspected anarchists and the 1950s communist deportations, warning against repeating the mistakes of history in the name of national security.

Quoting a dissenting opinion from a 1950 case, the judge wrote:

“Security is like liberty in that many are the crimes committed in its name.”

Allegations and Government Justification

The U.S. government, invoking the Immigration and Nationality Act, claims that Mahdawi’s continued presence in the country poses a threat to national security. Secretary of State Marco Rubio labeled Mahdawi’s activism as having serious foreign policy implications.

A government attorney cited a 2015 FBI investigation where Mahdawi allegedly made anti-Jewish remarks at a gun shop. However, the court noted that the FBI likely found those allegations to be fabricated, further undermining the justification for his detention.

A Wider Crackdown on Student Protesters

Mahdawi's case is not isolated. An Associated Press review revealed that since late March 2024, more than 1,000 students across the U.S. had their visas revoked or legal statuses terminated due to their involvement in protests against the war in Gaza. Many of these students have filed court challenges, prompting the federal government to announce a policy reversal for some affected individuals.

Other Notable Cases

• Mahmoud Khalil, Mahdawi’s Columbia peer, has been in detention for over eight weeks and missed the birth of his child. An immigration judge recently ruled that Khalil can be deported as a national security risk.

• Rümeysa Öztürk, a Turkish student at Tufts University, was detained after co-authoring a critical op-ed in her student newspaper. Her legal team claims it’s an act of retaliation.

These cases illustrate a pattern of targeting student activists, particularly those voicing dissent against U.S. foreign policy related to the Israel-Palestine conflict.

Columbia University’s Role and Response

Columbia University, once the staging ground for many of Mahdawi’s protests, has come under scrutiny for complying with federal demands under the Trump administration. However, after Mahdawi’s release, university spokesperson Millie Wert stated that “every person in the country deserves due process, regardless of citizenship status.”

Mahdawi’s Message to America and the World

Outside the Vermont courthouse, Mahdawi directly addressed President Donald Trump and his Cabinet, asserting his courage and determination:

“I am not afraid of you.”

He continued with a message of peace and resilience:

“If there is no fear, what is it replaced with? Love. Love is our way.”

He also emphasized the global impact of America’s actions, stating that "the rest of the world is watching."

Looking Ahead: Graduation and Legal Uncertainty

Mahdawi is now permitted to travel outside Vermont and plans to attend his graduation at Columbia University next month. He has also completed coursework and had planned to pursue a master’s degree at the Ivy League institution in the fall.

Despite his release, Mahdawi’s future in the U.S. remains uncertain. He is expected to appear remotely before an immigration judge in Louisiana. It remains unclear whether the U.S. government will appeal the release order.

Conclusion

Mohsen Mahdawi’s release marks a significant moment in the broader national conversation about freedom of speech, immigration, and the right to protest. As students continue to protest U.S. support for Israel’s military actions, cases like Mahdawi’s highlight the fragile balance between national security and constitutional freedoms.

His case serves as a symbol of resistance and resilience, inspiring students and activists nationwide. It also poses a challenge to the U.S. government’s narrative on immigration enforcement and calls attention to the need for legal reform in how dissenting voices are treated in academic spaces.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are Wagons Learning, Srigee DLM, Manoj Jewellers.

The Current active IPO are Kenrik Industries, Arunaya Organics.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.