CRPF constable faces action after marrying Pakistani woman without approval

Team Finance Saathi

    02/May/2025

What's covered under the Article:

  1. CRPF constable Munir Ahmed married a Pakistani woman via WhatsApp before departmental approval.

  2. He failed to report his wife's continued stay in India after visa expiry and other developments.

  3. The marriage violated CRPF conduct rules, prompting a disciplinary inquiry and possible action.

A Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) constable, Munir Ahmed, currently serving in the 41st Battalion, is under scrutiny after he married a Pakistani national, Menal Khan, through a WhatsApp video call without receiving official permission from the department. The incident has sparked concerns related to national security, procedural breaches, and legal violations.

Violation of CRPF Rules and Conduct

According to a detailed report reviewed by News18, the constable had initially sought departmental approval to marry the Pakistani woman. However, before any decision or permission could be granted, the marriage was solemnised on May 24, 2024, via a WhatsApp video calla move that contravenes Rule 21(3) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.

The rule clearly mandates that government servants must obtain prior approval before entering into matrimony with a foreign national, especially from countries like Pakistan, given the sensitive security implications.

Concerns Raised in Official Reports

The report highlights that CRPF Headquarters in J&K Zone had already raised red flags about granting approval. Officials opined that the request for marriage should not be granted, and a policy-level decision was necessary to handle such sensitive cases in the future.

“As the instant case requires a policy decision being a case of marriage with Pakistani girl and matter of national security… a policy decision should be taken for dealing with such type of cases,” the report states.

Security and Legal Red Flags

The controversy intensified when it was revealed that Menal Khan had entered India via Wagah Border on a tourist visa valid until March 22, 2025. Munir Ahmed, however, did not inform his department that his wife was still residing in India, a critical lapse in duty and disclosure.

Further, Ahmed claimed that his wife had applied for a Long-Term Visa (LTV), but this fact was also not communicated to his superiors. These omissions raised serious national security concerns, especially considering the ongoing threat perception post the recent Pahalgam terror attack.

Questionable Statements and Court Claims

In court, the constable asserted that CRPF had been informed about the marriage. However, there is no record of the department approving or being officially notified. The fact that the marriage took place digitally—without formal, legal procedures or in-person solemnisation—has further complicated its legal validity.

The report further notes that:

  • Menal Khan’s presence in India was unreported beyond her visa status.

  • The constable’s actions potentially misled authorities and the judiciary.

  • The unauthorised digital marriage raises concerns about documentation and verification.

Aftermath and Deportation Efforts

Amid rising tensions post the Pahalgam attack, the Government of India had directed deportation of all Pakistani nationals. Following this directive, Menal Khan was taken to Wagah Border for deportation. However, the Jammu and Kashmir High Court intervened and granted a 10-day stay on her deportation on April 29, 2025, allowing more time for legal evaluation.

What Rules Were Violated?

The constable is being held accountable under Rule 21(3) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964, which governs the personal conduct of public servants. This rule makes it mandatory for any government employee to inform and obtain prior approval before marrying a foreign national.

Multiple violations include:

  • Failure to wait for approval before marriage.

  • Concealment of spouse’s overstay in India.

  • Lack of clarity regarding visa status and updates.

  • Making unverified claims during court hearings.

Policy Implications for CRPF and Other Forces

This incident has not just triggered departmental action against one individual, but also reignited the need for clear, robust policies regarding inter-national marriages, particularly with individuals from hostile neighbouring nations. The CRPF’s J&K Zone has recommended that standardised policy-level frameworks be established to ensure that such cases are handled with due diligence and clarity.

This also includes:

  • Pre-marriage background checks on foreign nationals.

  • Mandatory approval processes before any legal step.

  • Periodic updates on visa status and residential whereabouts.

  • Disciplinary procedures for non-compliance or misrepresentation.

Conclusion

The case of CRPF Constable Munir Ahmed and his marriage to Pakistani national Menal Khan serves as a critical reminder of the delicate balance between personal liberty and national security for personnel serving in India's security apparatus. The use of digital platforms like WhatsApp to circumvent established protocols only amplifies the challenges of maintaining disciplinary order and transparency in the digital age.

The CRPF has made it clear that the incident is being taken seriously and disciplinary action is imminent. Meanwhile, legal proceedings regarding Menal Khan’s stay and deportation are pending in court.

In a security-sensitive environment like Jammu and Kashmir, the importance of strict adherence to procedural guidelines and full disclosure cannot be overstated.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are Srigee DLMManoj Jewellers.


The Current active IPO are Wagons LearningKenrik IndustriesArunaya Organics.


Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.


Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.

Related News
onlyfans leakedonlyfan leaksonlyfans leaked videos