The Supreme Court of India on Thursday delivered a significant verdict in the high-profile Renukaswamy murder case, cancelling the bail earlier granted to Kannada actor Darshan Thoogudeepa and six co-accused, including actress Pavithra Gowda. The decision came from a two-judge bench comprising Justices Jamshed Burjor Pardiwala and R Mahadevan, who strongly criticised the Karnataka High Court’s order for being mechanically passed and lacking judicial reasoning.

The Supreme Court observed that granting bail in such a matter could seriously impact the trial and potentially influence witnesses. The bench noted that the High Court’s order suffered from perversity and wrongly ventured into evaluating witness statements — a domain strictly reserved for the trial court. The apex court categorically stated that such intervention at the bail stage was inappropriate.

In its stern remarks, the court warned against any “five-star treatment” being provided to Darshan, Pavithra Gowda, or the five other accused while in custody. It made it clear that if any such privileges were extended, the superintendent and concerned officials would face immediate suspension. This reflects the judiciary’s intent to ensure that no accused, regardless of social standing or celebrity status, is above the law.

Justice Mahadevan’s pronouncement was hailed as a powerful statement of judicial integrity, asserting that “no man is above law or below it.” The judgment emphasised the importance of the rule of law in maintaining public confidence in the justice system.

Background of the Case

The case revolves around the murder of 33-year-old autodriver Renukaswamy, whose body was recovered from a drain in Bengaluru on June 9. The prosecution alleges that Renukaswamy was abducted and tortured to death by Darshan, Pavithra, and their associates after he allegedly sent obscene messages to Pavithra.

The incident quickly escalated into a major criminal investigation due to the involvement of prominent personalities from the Kannada film industry. Public outrage and media coverage kept the case in constant spotlight, with calls for a fair and impartial trial.

High Court’s Bail Order and Supreme Court Challenge

On December 13 last year, the Karnataka High Court granted bail to the seven accused, citing the prosecution’s failure to present adequate grounds for arrest. The decision was met with criticism from legal experts and victims’ families, who feared it might compromise the integrity of the investigation.

Subsequently, the Karnataka government approached the Supreme Court, seeking cancellation of the bail. The state argued that the High Court had overstepped its jurisdiction by making observations on witness statements and that the accused could use their influence to tamper with evidence or intimidate witnesses.

The Supreme Court agreed with these arguments, underscoring that in criminal matters, due process must prevail over celebrity status or public sentiment.

Court’s Strong Message to Authorities

The bench reiterated that law enforcement agencies must maintain strict neutrality, irrespective of an accused’s public profile. It also underlined the disciplinary consequences for officials who attempt to accord preferential treatment to influential individuals in custody.

The court’s remarks — “We do not ask anyone’s permission when we obey the law” — serve as a reminder that justice must be blind to status, wealth, or fame. This pronouncement is likely to set a strong precedent for future cases involving high-profile personalities.

Impact on the Film Industry and Public Perception

The cancellation of Darshan’s bail has sent shockwaves across the Kannada film industry, where he enjoys massive popularity. Several fan groups have expressed disappointment, while others have welcomed the decision as a step towards ensuring accountability.

Public opinion remains divided, with some supporters maintaining the actor’s innocence and critics pointing to the seriousness of the charges. However, the Supreme Court’s decision is being widely viewed as a victory for the rule of law and a clear message that justice will not be compromised under public or political pressure.

What Happens Next

Following the order, the police have been directed to arrest Darshan immediately. The trial court will now proceed with the case, and given the apex court’s observations, the process is expected to be closely monitored for fairness and transparency.

This case will likely continue to attract significant media attention, not only for its criminal aspects but also for its broader implications on celebrity accountability, judicial independence, and public trust in law enforcement.

The Renukaswamy murder case serves as a stark reminder that justice in India, when pursued with integrity, remains a leveller — bringing everyone, regardless of fame or influence, under the same legal framework.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are Mangal Electrical Industries, LGT Business Connextions, Vikram Solar, Gem Aromatics, Studio LSD, Shreeji Shipping Global, Patel Retail.

The Current active IPO are Regaal Resources, Mahendra Realtors and Infrastructure.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.