On July 8, 2025, India observed the 111th birth anniversary of Jyoti Basu, a towering figure in the Indian Left movement and one of the most enduring political personalities of post-Independence India. Known for his calm demeanour and decisive leadership, Basu served as West Bengal's Chief Minister for over 23 years, shaping the state's political landscape through landmark reforms and polarising decisions.

But among the many moments that defined his legacy, one stands apart—a decision made in 1996, when he declined the Prime Minister's post, a move he would later call a “historic blunder.”

The Missed Opportunity: 1996 Prime Ministerial Offer

After the fractured mandate of the 1996 Lok Sabha elections, a coalition of regional and Left parties formed the United Front. With the Congress offering external support, the coalition looked to a widely respected and seasoned leader to bring stability to the centre.

Jyoti Basu, then CM of West Bengal and a senior leader of the CPI(M), was unanimously chosen as the ideal candidate to lead the country. However, his party’s central committee vetoed the proposal, expressing concerns over whether a coalition government dominated by regional parties would allow for effective implementation of Marxist policies. They also questioned the ideological compromise in accepting a post while holding only 32 Lok Sabha seats.

Despite Basu's willingness to accept the post, the party’s objection sealed the decision. Years later, Basu himself criticised the move, calling it a “historic blunder”—a missed chance to bring Left governance to the national level.

Early Life and Political Influences

Jyoti Basu was born on July 8, 1914, in Kolkata to Dr Nishikanta Basu, a renowned homeopath, and Hemlata Devi. After early schooling at St. Xavier’s, he pursued a degree in English from Presidency College, Kolkata. In 1935, he left for London to study law at the Middle Temple.

It was during his stay in Britain that Basu’s political transformation began. He was influenced by the 1930 Chittagong uprising, and in London, he became an active participant in leftist and Marxist circles, attending lectures by Harold Laski and working with the India League led by V.K. Krishna Menon. Though he wished to join the Communist Party of Great Britain, he was advised against it by its general secretary, Harry Pollitt, due to his foreign citizenship status.

Basu returned to India in 1940, soon registering as a barrister at the Calcutta High Court, and quickly immersed himself in labour movements, becoming the first secretary of the Bengal Assam Railroad Workers Union in 1944.

From Underground Politics to CM’s Chair

Basu’s political career gained momentum post-Independence. He was elected to the West Bengal Legislative Assembly from Baranagar in 1952. As India transitioned into a republic, Basu emerged as one of the most significant figures of the Communist Party of India (Marxist).

Following the CPI split, Basu was among the original nine-member Polit Bureau of CPI(M), often referred to as the party’s Navratnas. For years, he oscillated between active leadership and underground existence, evading police crackdowns during periods of political unrest.

In 1977, in the aftermath of the Emergency, the Left Front came to power in West Bengal, and Basu became Chief Minister—a role he retained until 2000.

Transformational Reforms and Political Control

Basu's government undertook massive land reforms, notably under the “Operation Barga” initiative, which empowered sharecroppers. The three-tier panchayati raj system was institutionalised, giving local governance a stronger voice. Minimum wages for agricultural labourers and welfare schemes for the rural poor formed the cornerstone of his developmental vision.

These initiatives made Basu a folk hero in rural Bengal, redistributing land in a state long plagued by feudal agrarian structures.

However, critics noted that his focus on agrarian reforms came at the cost of industrial growth. West Bengal witnessed stagnation in manufacturing, with many businesses migrating to other states due to bureaucratic inertia and labour unrest.

Controversies and Governance Style

While hailed as a visionary, Basu’s governance also attracted criticism. His centralised leadership style led many to describe the CPI(M) government as autocratic. Decisions often bore his sole imprint, and internal dissent within the party was reportedly minimal.

One of the most debated policies was the removal of English from primary education, which many believed contributed to West Bengal’s decline in national competitive exams and private-sector employment.

He also faced heat for controversial remarks. One such instance involved his response to the rape of a Bangladeshi woman by a policeman, where he infamously said, “These things happen.” The bluntness of the comment was condemned widely and painted a callous image of the administration.

Retirement and Final Years

Basu retired from active politics in 2000, passing on leadership to his long-time deputy Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee. In 2008, due to deteriorating health, he stepped down from the Polit Bureau but remained a special invitee to the CPI(M)’s Central Committee.

On January 17, 2010, Jyoti Basu passed away at the age of 95. His death marked the end of an era—a symbol of pragmatic communism that tried to blend Marxist ideals with Indian governance models.

He is remembered fondly as the Iron Man of Bengal, a leader who never became Prime Minister but redefined what state-level leadership could achieve.

Legacy and Reflection

More than a decade after his passing, Jyoti Basu’s legacy remains complex—celebrated for land reforms and local governance, criticised for economic stagnation and autocratic tendencies. But most political observers agree that India missed a significant turning point in 1996, when it declined to install a communist leader at the helm of national power.

Had Basu become PM, India may have witnessed a new experiment in left-of-centre coalition governance—balancing economic equity with federal integrity.

His “historic blunder”, as he called it, still echoes in debates about the Left’s lost opportunity on the national stage.

As India marks his birth anniversary, Jyoti Basu’s journey from London’s Marxist classrooms to the corridors of Writers’ Building in Kolkata stands as a testament to ideological conviction, pragmatic governance, and one of the most extraordinary careers in Indian political history.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are NSDL, Spunweb Nonwoven, Smartworks Coworking, Asston Pharmaceuticals, CFF Fluid Control,  Anthem Biosciences.

The Current active IPO are Glen Industries, Smarten Power Systems, Travel Food Services, Chemkart India, Meta Infotech.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.