A fresh political storm has erupted in Karnataka after Congress MLA RV Deshpande, a senior legislator from Haliyal in Uttara Kannada, made a controversial remark to a woman journalist during a public interaction. The incident, which has now gone viral on social media, has drawn sharp criticism from the BJP, Janata Dal (Secular), and civil society groups, with calls for an apology.

The Incident: Journalist’s Question on Hospitals

During the interaction, the journalist raised a serious concern about the absence of hospital facilities in Joida taluk, a region where pregnant women and patients face difficulties due to the lack of medical infrastructure.

In response, RV Deshpande smiled, winked, and remarked: “Don’t worry, we’ll get yours done elsewhere.”

Taken aback, the journalist sought clarification, but Deshpande repeated himself, saying, “When it’s time for your delivery, we will get it done.”

Instead of assuring the public about building healthcare infrastructure, the MLA’s casual and personal remark sparked outrage, particularly because it was directed at a woman journalist raising a legitimate public concern.

The Journalist’s Appeal

Unfazed by the comment, the journalist pressed further, urging Deshpande to ensure that a hospital is built in the region during his current term. She highlighted how women in Joida taluk face immense challenges during pregnancy and delivery due to the absence of proper facilities.

The MLA gave only a brief “okay,” but offered no firm commitment, according to media reports.

Viral Video and Public Reaction

The video of the exchange quickly spread across social media platforms, drawing strong condemnation from netizens who accused the senior legislator of mocking women and trivialising serious healthcare issues.

Critics pointed out that such remarks are not only sexist and dismissive but also reflect poorly on the seriousness with which elected representatives address pressing public demands.

Political Fallout

The controversy soon took a political turn, with opposition parties demanding accountability.

• BJP Reaction:
  BJP spokesperson Vijay Prasad termed the comment as an “insult to mothers and women,” adding, “This is not politics, this is moral bankruptcy. Rahul Gandhi talks about love and respect, but his leaders spread hate and insult women.”

  BJP national spokesperson Shehzad Poonawalla also lashed out at Congress, saying, “Replying to a woman journalist like this? This adds to the long list of insults from Congress leaders. They talk about women empowerment but act otherwise.”

• JD(S) Reaction:
  The Janata Dal (Secular) also condemned Deshpande, sharing the video and demanding an apology. The party wrote: “To a senior journalist who asked for a super-specialty hospital for the district, you respond with ‘let it be your delivery’? Is this the respect you show to women?”

  The JD(S) statement further added, “As a senior legislator, your arrogant words are an insult to the dignity of women. Apologize immediately to that female journalist.”

Congress on the Defensive

While the Congress party has not issued an official statement yet, the incident has put it in an uncomfortable position, especially as it comes on the heels of other controversies involving remarks against women and political opponents’ families.

Deshpande, being a former state minister and a veteran leader, is expected to maintain a higher level of decorum. However, his remark has raised questions about the party’s commitment to gender sensitivity and respect for journalists.

Larger Issues: Women, Politics, and Public Accountability

This episode highlights a larger concern about the treatment of women in public spaces and the lack of seriousness with which healthcare issues are addressed in rural India.

The journalist’s original question was about the urgent need for a hospital in Joida taluk, where pregnant women reportedly face significant risks due to inadequate medical facilities. Instead of addressing the issue, the MLA’s remark shifted focus, drawing attention for all the wrong reasons.

The controversy also underscores the challenges journalists face when questioning powerful politicians. Often, instead of constructive responses, they encounter dismissive or condescending remarks, particularly if they are women.

Social Media Backlash

On platforms like X (formerly Twitter), Facebook, and Instagram, users have called out the MLA’s remarks as “sexist,” “insensitive,” and “disrespectful.” Many users pointed out that the issue raised was of public health importance, yet it was trivialised.

Some comments on social media read:

• “Instead of assuring action, he mocked a journalist asking a genuine question. This is shameful.”

• “This is why rural healthcare never improves—politicians don’t take it seriously.”

• “A woman journalist deserves respect, not humiliation in public.”

Healthcare in Uttara Kannada: The Core Issue

Behind the political noise lies the pressing issue of healthcare infrastructure in Joida and other rural parts of Uttara Kannada. Reports suggest that pregnant women often travel long distances for delivery, sometimes under unsafe conditions.

The absence of a well-equipped hospital in the region has been a longstanding demand, yet successive governments have failed to address it.

The journalist’s question highlighted a genuine governance gap, but the response she received exposed how such concerns are often brushed aside.

Conclusion

The controversy around RV Deshpande’s remark to a woman journalist has snowballed into a major political and social debate in Karnataka. While opposition parties are using it to corner the Congress, the larger issue remains the urgent need for hospitals and better healthcare facilities in rural areas like Joida.

The incident serves as a reminder that elected representatives must treat journalists, women, and citizens raising legitimate concerns with respect and seriousness. Anything less erodes public trust and deepens the disconnect between politicians and the people they serve.

As the video continues to circulate, pressure is mounting on Deshpande to issue a public apology, and on the Congress to take corrective action. Whether this controversy leads to tangible improvements in healthcare infrastructure or simply fades into another political slugfest remains to be seen.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are Taurian MPS, Jay Ambe Supermarkets, Krupalu Metals, Urban Company, Shringar House of Mangalsutra, Vashishtha Luxury Fashion, Karbonsteel Engineering, Sharvaya Metals, Vigor Plast India.

The Current active IPO are Austere Systems, Optivalue Tek Consulting, Goel Construction Company, Amanta Healthcare, Rachit Prints.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.