The National Stock Exchange of India Ltd. (NSE) has officially closed its investigation into potentially irregular trades conducted by Jane Street Group, a prominent US-based high-frequency trading firm. This decision comes after a series of internal reviews and responses from Jane Street’s trading partner in India, Nuvama Wealth Management Ltd., according to sources familiar with the matter.

Background: What Triggered the Investigation?

Earlier this year, in January 2025, the NSE flagged suspicious trades involving high-frequency trading (HFT) firms, including Jane Street. These trades reportedly involved swift reversals at prices that significantly deviated from prevailing market rates, raising alarms around possible market manipulation.

Such price movements can distort the price discovery mechanism in a market that is already seeing exponential growth in derivative trading. India’s derivatives market, led by NSE, is now the largest equity derivatives exchange in the world—a fact that makes regulatory scrutiny essential.

Details of the Trades

According to people with direct knowledge of the matter, the questionable trades were executed at lightning speed, with some orders reversed in milliseconds. Notably, some trades were done at prices well above or below market levels, a move that can mislead retail and institutional investors.

These actions came under the scanner as India’s regulators try to tighten control over F&O trading, especially with foreign institutional players (FIPs) like Jane Street increasing their influence in domestic markets.

Jane Street’s Billion-Dollar India Operations

Jane Street was thrust into the spotlight last year when a court case involving Millennium Management inadvertently revealed that the firm had earned $1 billion from trading Indian equity derivatives. This legal revelation not only shook the trading world but also put a magnifying glass on the role of algorithmic and high-frequency trading firms in India.

This massive earning caught the attention of both global financial circles and Indian regulators, prompting many to ask how a single foreign player could generate such enormous profits from a tightly regulated space.

NSE’s Response and Closure of the Case

The NSE sent an official notice to Nuvama Wealth Management, Jane Street’s local trading partner, earlier this year. This inquiry sought explanations for the trade behavior that was flagged during internal monitoring.

According to a letter dated April 30, 2025, reviewed by Bloomberg, the exchange has now closed the investigation following a response from Nuvama that appears to have satisfied the exchange’s regulatory requirements.

This means that, for now, no further action will be taken against Jane Street or its trading partners in India in relation to these specific trades.

High-Frequency Trading and Market Integrity

While Jane Street may have avoided penalties in this instance, the controversy highlights broader concerns about high-frequency trading (HFT) in India. Trades executed in milliseconds—faster than most retail traders can react—can lead to disparities in price execution and market depth.

Such concerns are not new globally, but India’s market, with its increasing retail participation and rising derivative volumes, is now at a crossroads where algorithmic precision collides with human investors’ trust.

The NSE, through its clearing arm NSE Clearing Ltd., claims to conduct real-time monitoring of positions and risk in the F&O segment. However, this episode suggests there’s still room for improvement when it comes to identifying potential manipulation before trades affect market sentiment.

No Official Comments from Jane Street or NSE

While the letter from NSE confirmed the closure of the investigation, neither Jane Street, Nuvama Wealth, nor NSE officials have offered public comments on the matter. The silence leaves room for continued speculation about whether this was a one-off event or a symptom of a larger issue brewing in India's equity derivatives landscape.

India’s Rapidly Growing Derivatives Market

India’s F&O segment has exploded in popularity, driven largely by retail investors, thanks to easy mobile trading access and low margin requirements. According to recent data, over 90% of NSE’s trading volumes now come from the derivatives segment, far surpassing cash market activity.

This growth has attracted major global players like Jane Street, who deploy complex algorithmic strategies to capitalize on arbitrage and volatility.

However, the regulatory framework has struggled to keep up, often reacting after trades have been executed. This Jane Street case could be a wake-up call for regulators to develop proactive risk detection tools.

Future Implications for the Indian Markets

The closure of this investigation does not mean the end of regulatory scrutiny. It’s likely that SEBI and NSE will increase oversight of high-speed trades, foreign entities, and derivative instruments, especially given the rising volumes and volatility in Indian markets.

Moreover, as India continues to be a favored destination for global capital, regulators must balance openness with accountability, ensuring that retail investors are not at a disadvantage in a market increasingly dominated by algorithms.

Key Takeaways

• Jane Street’s operations remain under the lens, despite this probe being closed.

• High-frequency trading strategies, though legal, pose ethical and systemic questions.

• Indian regulators may soon introduce tighter controls or new disclosures for foreign algorithmic traders.

Final Thoughts

While NSE has put a lid on this particular issue, the underlying concerns remain. The Indian stock market’s future will depend heavily on how well its regulators adapt to the complexities of modern trading—a space where speed, data, and algorithms now rule.

This event also serves as a cautionary tale for investors and policymakers alike: that the rules of the game are evolving, and so must the mechanisms that govern them.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are Integrity Borana Weaves, Belrise Industries, Wagons Learning.

The Current active IPO are Accretion Pharmaceuticals, Integrity Infrabuild Developers and Virtual Galaxy Infotech.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.