On May 20, 2025, the Supreme Court of India delivered a landmark verdict mandating a minimum of three years of legal practice for candidates aspiring to become Civil Judges (Junior Division). The ruling was passed by a bench led by Chief Justice of India BR Gavai, along with Justices AG Masih and K Vinod Chandran.

The apex court observed that the direct appointment of fresh law graduates as judges had led to significant challenges, particularly due to their lack of practical exposure in legal proceedings. Recognising that such inexperience hampers the effective discharge of judicial duties, the Court reinstated the three-year legal practice requirement to ensure aspirants gain adequate courtroom and legal practice experience before joining the judiciary.

Key Directives by the Supreme Court

The Court ordered all State governments to amend their rules so that candidates appearing for the Civil Judges (Junior Division) exam must possess a minimum of three years of legal practice. This experience must be certified by a lawyer with at least 10 years standing at the Bar, ensuring credibility and verifiability of the candidate's professional background.

In addition to legal practice, the Court also stated that experience as a law clerk to judges will be considered valid towards fulfilling this requirement. Moreover, all new judicial entrants must undergo a mandatory one-year training program before they begin presiding over cases, aiming to bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical judicial functioning.

Non-Retroactive Rule Application

Importantly, the Court clarified that this minimum practice rule will not affect ongoing recruitment processes. It will apply only to future judicial recruitment cycles. The Court emphasized that any recruitment process already underway for appointing Civil Judges (Junior Division) will be exempt from this requirement.

This ensures fairness and avoids disruption for candidates currently in the pipeline while setting a higher standard for all subsequent appointments.

Calculation of Practice Period

The Court further clarified that the three-year practice period will be counted from the date of provisional enrollment as an advocate, rather than the date of passing the All India Bar Examination (AIBE). This is because the AIBE is held at different times, and counting from provisional enrollment provides a more uniform and consistent measure of practice duration.

Rationale Behind the Verdict

The Supreme Court expressed concern over the lack of practical skills and courtroom exposure among fresh law graduates appointed directly to the judiciary. Such appointments have reportedly created challenges on the ground, affecting the quality of judicial functioning and case management.

By mandating this practice period, the Court aims to improve the overall competency of judicial officers, ensuring they are better prepared to handle complex legal issues, manage court proceedings efficiently, and deliver justice effectively.

Implications for Judicial Recruitment and Training

This verdict represents a significant step in judicial reforms, focusing on quality over quantity in the appointment of judges. It encourages prospective judicial officers to gain hands-on experience through legal practice or clerking before assuming judicial responsibilities.

The one-year training further strengthens this objective by providing structured guidance, orientation, and skill development tailored to judicial roles. State governments and judicial academies will need to align their recruitment and training frameworks with the Supreme Court’s directives.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court's decision to reinstate the minimum three-year legal practice requirement for Civil Judges (Junior Division) marks a critical development in India's judicial recruitment process. By emphasizing practical experience and structured training, the apex court seeks to enhance the quality and efficiency of the judiciary, benefiting the legal system and society at large.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are Blue Water Logistics, Unified Data - Tech Solutions, Dar Credit and Capital, Belrise Industries, Wagons Learning.

The Current active IPO are Victory Electric Vehicles International, Borana Weaves.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.