The recent Pahalgam terror attack on April 22, which resulted in the tragic death of 26 individuals including Indian Navy Lieutenant Vinay Narwal, has stirred deep emotional responses from across the nation. Amid this heartbreaking loss, Vinay’s wife, Himanshi Narwal, made a powerful yet controversial appeal for peace in the wake of the violence. However, her plea did not go unchallenged and instead sparked an intense backlash on social media.

Himanshi Narwal’s Call for Peace

On May 1, 2023, during a camp organized by the National Integrated Forum of Artists and Activists, Himanshi, sitting beside a photo of her late husband, shared a message calling for peace. The image of Himanshi and Vinay, taken before the tragedy, became viral when a Studio Ghibli-style version of it started circulating on social media. Himanshi’s message was simple but poignant: “I just want the entire nation to pray for him, that wherever he is, he remains healthy and happy…We don’t want people going against Muslims or Kashmiris. We want peace and only peace. Of course, we want justice.”

This statement, made on what would have been Vinay Narwal's birthday, was meant to advocate for unity and tranquility in the midst of the violent attack. However, her remarks did not resonate well with everyone. In the age of social media, where opinions often clash, Himanshi found herself being trolled relentlessly by users online.

Backlash from Social Media

While Himanshi’s message was intended to bridge divides and prevent the escalation of hate, social media users were quick to criticize her. Some users took to platforms like X to mock her comments, with one user suggesting that she would take her in-laws' properties and leave them destitute. Others expressed disbelief at the fact that a woman, whose husband had been killed in such a horrific attack, was advocating for peace instead of seeking revenge.

Furthermore, her personal life and marriage came under intense scrutiny. The fact that Himanshi and Vinay had tied the knot just six days before the attack, with their honeymoon destination being Pahalgam, led to further criticism. Some claimed that Himanshi’s choice of Pahalgam was suspicious, asserting that it had been her idea, despite reports claiming that their plans were altered due to delays in securing a visa for Switzerland.

Himanshi’s Academic and Ideological Background

Adding to the controversy were accusations regarding Himanshi’s academic background. As a PhD scholar from Gurugram, some users linked her educational journey to leftist ideologies. Social media trolls, citing her “JNU roots,” suggested that her comments were more about absolving terrorists and supporting Pakistan than about advocating for peace. This remark reflected the polarizing political climate surrounding sensitive issues like terrorism and religious divisions.

Support from Asaduddin Owaisi

Amid the trolling, Himanshi did receive support from some quarters. One of the strongest voices in her defense came from Asaduddin Owaisi, the leader of the All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM). Owaisi expressed his admiration for Himanshi’s grace under pressure and criticized the hate-filled rhetoric surrounding the incident. He pointed out that despite enduring such immense personal loss, Himanshi’s call for peace showed remarkable resilience and strength. “They (terrorists) devastated our daughter's (Himanshi’s) life, and yet, even in her grief, she expressed that she does not wish for this tragedy to create hatred towards Muslims or Kashmiris in our country," Owaisi said.

The AIMIM leader went on to highlight that those who were spreading hate were, in essence, serving the interests of the very terrorists who perpetrated the attack. Owaisi’s words were a clarion call for unity and understanding, urging the government and people to remember Himanshi’s noble message and not let the tragedy be a tool for further division.

National Commission for Women Steps In

In response to the hateful comments, the National Commission for Women (NCW) intervened to address the situation. The NCW condemned the trolling of Himanshi Narwal, emphasizing that it was wrong to target a woman for expressing her personal views and grieving her loss. In a strongly worded statement, the NCW reminded the public of the importance of respecting a woman’s ideological stance and personal choices, especially in the face of such unspeakable tragedy.

The Bigger Issue at Hand

While the immediate focus has been on Himanshi’s comments and the backlash she faced, the situation also sheds light on the ongoing issue of how online platforms can become breeding grounds for hate and misinformation. In a time when public figures are often judged harshly for their personal opinions, it is important to remember that voices advocating for peace, unity, and forgiveness deserve respect, especially when coming from someone who has suffered the ultimate loss.

Moreover, Himanshi’s stance is also a reminder of the deeply-rooted divides in the region, particularly in Kashmir. Her plea for peace between communities, irrespective of religion or origin, is an echo of the desire for a more harmonious society. This sentiment, however, is not always easy to uphold in the face of brutal violence and loss, making Himanshi’s message all the more poignant.

As the investigation into the Pahalgam terror attack continues and justice is sought for the victims, it is crucial that the nation reflects on the broader implications of the tragedy. Instead of succumbing to hate or divisiveness, the focus should be on healing, reconciliation, and a united stand against terrorism.

In the end, Himanshi Narwal's appeal for peace represents the kind of compassion and strength needed to rise above the hate and violence that too often permeate discussions around such tragedies. It is a reminder that, even in the darkest of times, the call for peace can be both an act of courage and a vision for a better future.

The Current active IPO are Srigee DLM, Manoj Jewellers, Wagons Learning, Kenrik Industries.

The Closed IPOs are  Arunaya Organic, Ather Energy, Iware Supplychain Services.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.