US President Donald Trump has signed an executive order to initiate the process of dismantling the US Department of Education, marking a historic shift in the country’s education policy. Announced on March 21, 2025, this move aims to return authority over education to states and local communities. While key initiatives such as Pell Grants and Title I funding for children with disabilities will be reassigned to other federal agencies, Trump stated that the Department of Education had not delivered on its promise of improving educational outcomes despite decades of increased federal spending.

Trump’s Reasoning for Dismantling the Department

Donald Trump has long criticized the Department of Education for being inefficient and ineffective, arguing that federal oversight has failed to improve American education. Speaking at the signing of the executive order, Trump said:
"Today we take a very historic action that was 45 years in the making. I will sign an executive order to begin eliminating the Federal Department of Education once and for all. Democrats know it's right. I hope they're going to be voting for it because ultimately it may come before them. We have to get our children educated. We're not doing well with the education in this country and we haven't for a long time."

Trump emphasized that state and local authorities are better positioned to make decisions that meet the unique needs of their communities. According to him, the federal government's centralized control over education has led to stagnation and poor outcomes.

Criticism of the Department of Education

Conservative critics, including Trump, have frequently argued that the Department of Education is heavily influenced by liberal ideologies and does not reflect the diverse educational priorities of different states. Established in 1979 under President Jimmy Carter's administration, the department was met with opposition not only from Republicans but also from some members of Carter's own cabinet.

Trump’s criticism echoes a broader conservative sentiment that education policy should be determined locally rather than through a centralized federal agency. His latest move marks the beginning of a significant shift in the federal government’s role in education, empowering state and local governments to take charge of their own education policies.

White House Data Highlights Department’s Shortcomings

White House data paints a grim picture of the Department of Education’s performance over the past four decades. Since its establishment in 1979, the department has spent over USD 3 trillion on education, but student outcomes have remained stagnant.

• Per-pupil spending has increased by over 245% since 1979, yet test scores remain flat.
• Math and reading scores for 13-year-olds are at their lowest levels in decades.
• 40% of fourth graders do not meet basic reading levels.
• 6 in 10 fourth graders and nearly three-quarters of eighth graders are not proficient in math.
• US students rank 28 out of 37 OECD countries in math performance.

These statistics, combined with rising dissatisfaction among parents and educators, have reinforced Trump’s belief that federal control has hindered educational progress.

What Happens to Pell Grants and Title I Funding?

While the Department of Education itself will be dismantled, Trump assured that vital programs such as Pell Grants and Title I funding will be protected and reassigned to other federal agencies. Pell Grants provide financial aid for low-income college students, while Title I funding supports educational programs for disadvantaged children. These programs will continue under different administrative structures to ensure that critical resources remain accessible.

Local Control and Decentralization

The executive order aims to empower states and local communities by giving them greater control over education policy and decision-making. Conservatives argue that decentralizing authority will allow for customized education strategies that align with local values and priorities.

Trump’s order suggests that state and local governments are better suited to address challenges and implement policies that serve their communities effectively. This decentralization is expected to result in greater accountability and innovation within the education sector.

Criticism and Support

Critics of Trump’s move warn that dismantling the Department of Education could lead to disparities in educational quality across states. They argue that a federal framework ensures minimum standards for educational equality and protects the rights of marginalized students. However, supporters believe that returning control to local authorities will enhance responsiveness and accountability in education.

Historical Context: Creation of the Department

The US Department of Education was created in 1979 by President Jimmy Carter to centralize education policy and ensure uniform standards across the country. However, critics have long maintained that the department has failed to deliver on its promises despite decades of federal intervention.

The department’s primary functions have included:

• Administering federal financial aid programs such as Pell Grants and student loans.
• Collecting and analyzing educational data to identify trends and inform policy decisions.
• Ensuring compliance with federal education laws and promoting equal educational opportunities.

Long-Term Implications

Dismantling the Department of Education is expected to reshape the educational landscape in the US. It could lead to greater diversity in educational approaches but may also create inequalities in standards and outcomes. As the responsibility for education shifts to the states, governors and local authorities will play a greater role in shaping policies that align with their communities' needs.

Conclusion

Trump’s decision to dismantle the Department of Education marks a historic turning point in US education policy. By returning authority to states and local communities, the executive order seeks to empower local decision-makers and foster innovative approaches to education. However, the long-term impact of this move remains to be seen, as supporters and critics debate its potential consequences on the quality and equality of education in America.

The Upcoming IPOs in this week and coming weeks are Arisinfra Solutions Limited, Desco Infratech Limited, ATC Energies System Limited, Shri Ahimsa Naturals Limited.

The Current active IPO are Rapid Fleet Management Services, Active Infrastructures Limited,Grand Continental Hotels.

Start your Stock Market Journey and Apply in IPO by Opening Free Demat Account in Choice Broking FinX.

Join our Trading with CA Abhay Telegram Channel for regular Stock Market Trading and Investment Calls by CA Abhay Varn - SEBI Registered Research Analyst.